Is 5new Worth 42.00? Here's the Truth

Is 5new Worth 42.00? Here's the Truth

My Verdict: 4.9/5
Best For: Minimalists & anyone after a salon-quality everyday stud.
Price: 42.00

I tried the 5new earrings for a week straight. I’m honest. These surprised me. They look stunning. Properly luxe without shouting.

First up — Handmade in Australia. Huge plus. You can tell from the finish. My pair felt carefully made. Not like the cheap, mass-produced stuff you grab at the mall. These have that near-salon/store quality. Clean edges. Consistent plating. The kind of little details that make them feel expensive.

Comfort is solid. I wore them during a long day of errands and a dinner out. No itch. No drama. They sit nicely. My lobes didn’t scream after a few hours. If you have super-sensitive ears, ask about the posts. Mine were fine, but everyone’s skin is different.

Style wise, they’re low-key but classy. They finish outfits. I reckon they’d work for casual coffee runs or a dressier night. They don’t scream trend-chasing. They’re the kind of studs you can wear on repeat.

How they compare to salon/store pieces

Honestly? They feel as good as mid-range store jewellery. Better than the cheap stuff from trend shops. Not quite high-end jeweller sparkle, but close. For the price, they punch above their weight. The handmade touch lifts them well above mass-market finds.

Pros & Cons

  • Pro: Lasts well with normal wear. I got about two weeks of daily wear before noticeable dulling.
  • Pro: Handmade in Australia. That craft shows.
  • Pro: Salon/store quality finish for the price.
  • Pro: Comfortable for long wear. Cute, minimal design that suits heaps of outfits.
  • Con: Needs careful removal. Take them off before sleeping or showering to keep the plating.
  • Con: Slightly heavier than ultra-light studs. If you’ve tiny lobes, they might feel chunky.
  • Con: Not solid gold. Plating will show wear over months if not cared for.

Overall, I reckon these are a win. They feel grown-up without being boring. If you want a pair that looks like you spent more than you did — go for it. If you’re after forever jewellery, consider solid-gold options instead.

FAQ

How long does it last?
I got about two weeks of daily wear before the shine dulled a touch. With careful care (no sleeping with them, avoid perfume on the posts, wipe them after wear) you can stretch that to months of good-looking use. Long-term, plating will wear eventually.

Is it waterproof?
Not fully. They handle a splash or quick wash. But don’t swim or shower in them. Chlorine and salt speed up wear. I take mine off before the beach or pool. Keeps them looking sharp longer.

Want to see them? Click here: 5new.

🛍️ GET THIS LOOK (Direct Checkout)

Ships fast from Australia 🇦🇺

Back to blog